How to Choose Between Gate Valves, Ball Valves, and Butterfly Valves
On this page
In industrial piping systems, gate valves, ball valves, and butterfly valves are the three most commonly used types of shut-off valves. While all three serve the basic function of controlling flow, they differ significantly in design, performance, and suitable operating conditions. Choosing the wrong type can lead to frequent failures, reduced operational efficiency, and even safety risks.
This article aims to provide a clear yet professional guide to help you quickly determine which valve is most appropriate for different applications.
1.Extremely Low Flow Resistance
When fully open, the medium flows almost straight through the valve, resulting in minimal pressure drop. This makes gate valves highly suitable for long-distance pipeline transport.
2.Best for Fully Open or Fully Closed Operation
Gate valves are not recommended for flow regulation. Operating in a partially open state can cause gate vibration and erosion, reducing valve lifespan.
3.Suitable for High-Temperature and High-Pressure Conditions
Thanks to their reliable metal-to-metal sealing, gate valves are widely used in steam, high-temperature oil, and chemical process systems.
Typical Applications:
● Power plant steam lines
● Petrochemical facilities
● High-pressure and high-temperature systems
● Long-distance pipelines
Not Recommended For:
● Space-constrained installations
● Applications requiring frequent operation or flow modulation
1.Quick Operation and Easy Handling
Requires only a quarter turn (90°) to fully open or close, making it ideal for systems that require frequent switching.
2.Excellent Sealing Performance
Soft-seated ball valves can achieve near “bubble-tight” sealing, suitable for applications with high sealing requirements.
3.Smooth Flow Path, Suitable for Medium to Low Pressure Systems
Full bore ball valves offer minimal flow resistance, ensuring efficient flow control.
4.Temperature Limitations for Soft-Seated Valves
Soft seats are generally not recommended for high-temperature steam. Metal-seated ball valves can be used for high-temperature applications, though at a higher cost.
Typical Applications:
● Natural gas and fuel gas systems
● Petrochemical processes (medium to low pressure)
● Water treatment systems
● Food and pharmaceutical industries
● Precision fluid control systems
Not Recommended For:
● Extremely high temperatures or pressures
● Abrasive or particle-laden media
1. Cost-Effective and Space-Saving Design
Compared with gate and ball valves of the same size, butterfly valves are significantly smaller and require less installation space.
2.Low Operating Torque
The lightweight disc reduces torque requirements, making butterfly valves suitable for automated operation such as pneumatic or electric actuators.
3.Suitable for Throttling
Centerline and double-eccentric designs can handle basic flow regulation in addition to on/off service.
4.Multiple Sealing Options
● Soft-seated butterfly valves: Best for ambient-temperature and clean media.
●Double- and triple-eccentric metal-seated butterfly valves: Suitable for higher temperatures, mild corrosion, and medium-pressure systems.
Typical Applications:
● HVAC systems
● Water supply and drainage
● Large-diameter pipelines
● Clean or mildly corrosive fluids
Not Recommended For:
● Zero-leakage requirements
● High-pressure applications
● High-velocity or severe erosive conditions
1. Medium Characteristics
Fluids with particles or sewage: Choose gate valves or metal-seated butterfly valves.
Clean fluids: All three valve types are suitable.
Gas or compressed air: Ball valves or butterfly valves are preferred.
High-temperature steam: Gate valves or triple-offset butterfly valves.
2. Valve Size
Small diameters (below DN50): Ball valves are the most commonly used.
Medium diameters (DN50–DN300): Any of the three types are applicable.
Large diameters (above DN300): Butterfly valves offer advantages in cost and weight.
3. Pressure and Temperature Requirements
High pressure: Gate valve ＞ ball valve ＞ butterfly valve.
High temperature: Gate valves or metal-seated butterfly valves.
Medium to low pressure: Butterfly valves deliver the best cost-performance ratio.
4. Operating Frequency
Frequent operation: Ball valves are the optimal choice.
Occasional operation: Gate valves and butterfly valves are both suitable.
By assessing the medium, size, pressure, temperature, and operating frequency, you can generally determine the most appropriate valve type for your application.
If you are still unsure which valve is best suited for your application, feel free to contact us for professional selection support, system optimization advice, or valve replacement solutions.
Soft-seated ball valves are not suitable. Metal-seated ball valves can withstand high temperatures, but they come with higher costs.
Q2: Can butterfly valves achieve zero leakage?
Soft-seated butterfly valves can reach near-zero leakage, while triple-offset metal-seated butterfly valves can also achieve zero-leakage ratings when manufactured with high precision.
Q3: Can gate valves be used for throttling?
Not recommended. Using gate valves for flow regulation can cause erosion and vibration of the gate, leading to premature failure.
Q4: Why are butterfly valves commonly used in large-diameter pipelines?
Because butterfly valves are lightweight, cost-effective, structurally simple, and require lower operating torque—making them ideal for electric or pneumatic actuators.
This article aims to provide a clear yet professional guide to help you quickly determine which valve is most appropriate for different applications.
1. Gate Valve — Ideal for Fully Open or Fully Closed Applications with Minimal Flow Resistance
Gate valves feature a wedge or parallel gate design, operating by the vertical movement of the gate to control flow. Their key characteristics include:1.Extremely Low Flow Resistance
When fully open, the medium flows almost straight through the valve, resulting in minimal pressure drop. This makes gate valves highly suitable for long-distance pipeline transport.
2.Best for Fully Open or Fully Closed Operation
Gate valves are not recommended for flow regulation. Operating in a partially open state can cause gate vibration and erosion, reducing valve lifespan.
3.Suitable for High-Temperature and High-Pressure Conditions
Thanks to their reliable metal-to-metal sealing, gate valves are widely used in steam, high-temperature oil, and chemical process systems.
Typical Applications:
● Power plant steam lines
● Petrochemical facilities
● High-pressure and high-temperature systems
● Long-distance pipelines
Not Recommended For:
● Space-constrained installations
● Applications requiring frequent operation or flow modulation
2. Ball Valve — Superior Sealing with Fast On/Off Operation
Ball valves control flow by rotating a spherical ball 90°, with sealing options available in soft or metal-to-metal configurations.1.Quick Operation and Easy Handling
Requires only a quarter turn (90°) to fully open or close, making it ideal for systems that require frequent switching.
2.Excellent Sealing Performance
Soft-seated ball valves can achieve near “bubble-tight” sealing, suitable for applications with high sealing requirements.
3.Smooth Flow Path, Suitable for Medium to Low Pressure Systems
Full bore ball valves offer minimal flow resistance, ensuring efficient flow control.
4.Temperature Limitations for Soft-Seated Valves
Soft seats are generally not recommended for high-temperature steam. Metal-seated ball valves can be used for high-temperature applications, though at a higher cost.
Typical Applications:
● Natural gas and fuel gas systems
● Petrochemical processes (medium to low pressure)
● Water treatment systems
● Food and pharmaceutical industries
● Precision fluid control systems
Not Recommended For:
● Extremely high temperatures or pressures
● Abrasive or particle-laden media
3. Butterfly Valve — Lightweight, Cost-Effective, and Ideal for Large Diameters
A butterfly valve controls flow by rotating a circular disc (the vane). Its compact design and low weight make it a preferred choice for large-diameter piping systems.1. Cost-Effective and Space-Saving Design
Compared with gate and ball valves of the same size, butterfly valves are significantly smaller and require less installation space.
2.Low Operating Torque
The lightweight disc reduces torque requirements, making butterfly valves suitable for automated operation such as pneumatic or electric actuators.
3.Suitable for Throttling
Centerline and double-eccentric designs can handle basic flow regulation in addition to on/off service.
4.Multiple Sealing Options
● Soft-seated butterfly valves: Best for ambient-temperature and clean media.
●Double- and triple-eccentric metal-seated butterfly valves: Suitable for higher temperatures, mild corrosion, and medium-pressure systems.
Typical Applications:
● HVAC systems
● Water supply and drainage
● Large-diameter pipelines
● Clean or mildly corrosive fluids
Not Recommended For:
● Zero-leakage requirements
● High-pressure applications
● High-velocity or severe erosive conditions
4. How to Quickly Select the Right Valve Based on Operating Conditions
To simplify valve selection, you can evaluate the application from four key aspects:1. Medium Characteristics
Fluids with particles or sewage: Choose gate valves or metal-seated butterfly valves.
Clean fluids: All three valve types are suitable.
Gas or compressed air: Ball valves or butterfly valves are preferred.
High-temperature steam: Gate valves or triple-offset butterfly valves.
2. Valve Size
Small diameters (below DN50): Ball valves are the most commonly used.
Medium diameters (DN50–DN300): Any of the three types are applicable.
Large diameters (above DN300): Butterfly valves offer advantages in cost and weight.
3. Pressure and Temperature Requirements
High pressure: Gate valve ＞ ball valve ＞ butterfly valve.
High temperature: Gate valves or metal-seated butterfly valves.
Medium to low pressure: Butterfly valves deliver the best cost-performance ratio.
4. Operating Frequency
Frequent operation: Ball valves are the optimal choice.
Occasional operation: Gate valves and butterfly valves are both suitable.
By assessing the medium, size, pressure, temperature, and operating frequency, you can generally determine the most appropriate valve type for your application.
5. Conclusion
Gate valves, ball valves, and butterfly valves each offer distinct advantages and have specific application boundaries. Selecting the right valve type can significantly improve system stability, reduce maintenance costs, and enhance operating efficiency. For real-world projects, it is recommended to evaluate standards, equipment requirements, and long-term maintenance costs to make an informed decision.If you are still unsure which valve is best suited for your application, feel free to contact us for professional selection support, system optimization advice, or valve replacement solutions.
Q&A – Frequently Asked Questions
Q1: Can ball valves be used for high-temperature steam?Soft-seated ball valves are not suitable. Metal-seated ball valves can withstand high temperatures, but they come with higher costs.
Q2: Can butterfly valves achieve zero leakage?
Soft-seated butterfly valves can reach near-zero leakage, while triple-offset metal-seated butterfly valves can also achieve zero-leakage ratings when manufactured with high precision.
Q3: Can gate valves be used for throttling?
Not recommended. Using gate valves for flow regulation can cause erosion and vibration of the gate, leading to premature failure.
Q4: Why are butterfly valves commonly used in large-diameter pipelines?
Because butterfly valves are lightweight, cost-effective, structurally simple, and require lower operating torque—making them ideal for electric or pneumatic actuators.
